The easiest YES of my life

Well, we reached the halfway point of the year and all was quiet on the proposal front. However, we had a lot of trips planned so I made sure to keep my head on a swivel. I know, I know… he said I won’t see it coming, but doesn’t it seem like a trip would be the perfect time to propose? Um yes.

So we make it through summer, we enter early fall… and nothing. Of course, I asked often. I know I started to drive Dayne crazy, but can you really blame me? As we entered holiday season, I felt the pressure building. We only had a couple months left of the year and we were going to be traveling like crazy for Thanksgiving, Christmas, and New Years. So it had to be close.

Thanksgiving comes and goes, now it’s time to head to Orlando for a long weekend. We had planned to go to Universal for two days with my parents as an early Christmas present. Now you might be wondering, Jordy why do we care? Well… here’s a funny story.

The day before we are supposed to leave for Florida, I was heading to work - running late because… life - when I realized I forgot my work ID in my coat from the night before. I call Dayne to confirm and he says it’s there. He offers to meet me halfway, I tell him since I was already going to be late and I needed to leave the office early anyways, it just made more sense for me to work from home. Dayne hesitates for a minute but then quickly says no worries. As soon as I hang up with him, my mom starts calling me. Then my dad starts calling me. Alright, what’s going on? I’m already frustrated with running behind and forgetting my wallet. Now, I’m being inundated with calls. Something is up…

I get home, and just as I’m about to get settled, Dayne asks if I want to go to a coffeeshop to work so he can get to bed (he works overnights for his job). That’s very odd since he loves when I work from home. And now his phone starts ringing like crazy. WELL… come to find out my ring was being delivered at that very moment and that’s why he wanted me to leave. That’s also why my parents were calling because they were checking to see where I was because Dayne texted them about the whole situation. Of course I feel terrible now because I ruined the surprise!!!!! So I quickly pack up and head to Starbucks to work so he can go meet the delivery driver and take a look at the ring. While I am on the phone with my mom talking about this whole mess of a morning she goes, “oh wow… that’s so beautiful!” Dayne had sent her a picture of the ring. So now I knew it was gorgeous (duh) and that it was in the apartment somewhere. Torture. Absolute torture.

Trip to Orlando, nothing. Christmas Eve, nothing. Christmas Day, nothing. Just six days remained in 2025 and now, I start questioning, will it actually happen this year? Will he wait another month for our anniversary, my birthday, his birthday or Valentine’s Day? Possibly!

And then…

December 30, 2025 | We had plans to go to The Edgewater Hotel in Madison, WI, to go ice skating with our good friend Arman. Now this hotel has a special place in our love story. We had our first date at The Statehouse restaurant and we had gone ice skating here a few years earlier. So, one would conclude it was happening on this night. Well, after telling me so many times that I won’t see it coming, I truly believed it couldn’t be this obvious. He really got me with the reverse psychology. So we get ready, we start to drive into town. I don’t see a ring box in his pockets so I just went with the flow. Arman told us he had the tickets and would meet us at the hotel when he wrapped up at work. Well, we get parked, we head toward where the rink is and there’s nobody outside. The rink doesn’t have a single skater on it, the terrace is empty… Of course, Dayne being quick on his feet suggests that they might have just cleaned the ice and are waiting for the next time slot before letting people on it. That makes sense, so I went with it (come to find out the rink was actually closed that night). We walk toward the backside of the terrace, which is decorated so beautifully for Christmas. All the trees are lit up, the fire pits are going, music drifts through the air. And now the energy shifts. Please enjoy this exchange…

Dayne: I love you so much, Jordy.

Me: Aw, I love you so much, Dayne. *Internally starts to freak out because it might be happening.

We approach the back railing that overlooks one of Madison’s two main lakes. Dayne looks nervous and like he wants to say something to which I blurt out…

Me: Hey honey, do you think the lake is frozen? *Still internally freaking out because it might be happening soon.

Dayne: Um… I don’t know. Anyways, I have thought a lot about how I would do this…

Me: OH MY GOD IT’S HAPPENING!

And then I blacked out.

The next thing I knew I was yelling YES, crying the happiest of tears, and hugging Dayne. It was absolutely perfect. And I’m so thankful he asked in a city that means so much to us, since Madison is where we met and fell in love, and he asked on the grounds of where our first date happened.

It was a truly magical moment. Next up, letting everyone know we were ENGAGED!

Next
Next

Pre-proposal wedding planning